Interview Transcript: Keita Takahashi, May 2025

As a freelance writer, uncertainty is a constant. In order to have my work published, I must not only write a decent article, but also to come up with a concept, set up interviews, liaison with PR agencies, pitch my ideas, and pray constantly that those ideas align with the needs and wants of the editors and magazines to which I pitch.

Retro Gamer Magazine has been a joy to write for since they accepted my first pitch sometime in early-2024, and the editorial team at the magazine is excellent in all ways. But being published is never guaranteed, nor do I take it for granted.

In April 2025, I reached out to Keita Takahashi to arrange an interview, thinking Retro Gamer might be interested in publishing some sort of feature on this singularly gifted game creator. I never really expected that I’d get to chat with Takahashi, a game designer whose work I have adored for over 20 years, but remarkably, he wrote back almost immediately and we set a date. This good fortune was even more surprising when you consider that his new game, To a T, was nearing the end of its development and was due to release in just a month’s time.

I conducted the interview in May, and though I was nervous to talk with someone whose work I had loved for so long, Takahashi ended up being one of the kindest and most thoughtful creators that I’ve had the pleasure of interviewing. It was truly special for me, and I’ll be forever grateful.

The article itself took some effort to get rolling, but eventually, Retro Gamer Magazine accepted my pitch and “The Making of Katamari Damacy” was published in issue 274. That article contains a number of key moments from my conversation with Takahashi, however, due to space and scope of focus, much of the interview is not included in the magazine.

Here is the complete, barely-edited transcript of my conversation with Keita Takahashi.

---

Keita Takahashi: Hello!

James Tocchio: Hello!

Keita Takahashi: How are you?

James Tocchio: I’m very well! I see the Prince behind you. [The Prince from Takahashi’s first game, Katamari Damacy, sits on a shelf just over Takahashi’s shoulder.] Is this your work studio?

Keita Takahashi: I mean, it's a garage. Why I'm wearing the jacket. It's so cold.

James Tocchio: Well, I'm so thrilled to talk to you, and the editors at the magazine are so happy that you were able to find the time. So I thank you for that and thank you, as well, as a fan. I've been a fan of your work for a long time, and the things you've made have brought me a lot of joy.

Keita Takahashi: Thank you. Thank you for playing my stupid games.

James Tocchio: And thanks again for the demo access to To a T [Keita’s newest game, unreleased at the time of this interview.] We've played that a few times and love it, my two young daughters played as well.

Keita Takahashi: Oh, how old?

James Tocchio: They are 8 and 9.

Keita Takahashi: Okay.

James Tocchio: They're obsessed with it. I catch them humming the songs that the giraffe sings. And then the other day I walked upstairs from my work office, and they had drawn this little drawing of your giraffe character. [Shows Takahashi a drawing of the character Giraffe.]

Keita Takahashi: Perfect.

James Tocchio: You must be very busy right now.

Keita Takahashi: Yeah, I'm sorry in advance. My brain is. My brain is still stuck in the work, so maybe it's not ready to give proper answer interviewing? But I will do my best.

James Tocchio: You're getting close to the end of the development cycle.

Keita Takahashi: Yeah, I think so. Yes, at least. For the day one patch. I have to keep working on additional patch.

James Tocchio: The release date is in May.

Keita Takahashi: Yeah, may 28th

James Tocchio: You're very close. So, I’m interested in chatting with you about your career and of course Katamari [Retro Gamer Magazine had commissioned me to write a feature titled “The Making of Katamari Damacy” published in Retro Gamer #274]. But I would also like to chat about To a T.

So if you don't mind, do you think we could start with the early days. What was your first job in the game industry?

Keita Takahashi: My first job was the artist, 3D artist of the Arcade Game Department in Namco.

James Tocchio: Do you remember any of the games that you worked on at that time?

Keita Takahashi: To be honest, I didn't make any product at all. I know the other people who join with me were able to ship some consumer products for the arcade, but I'm not. I was so picky about the project. Also, my boss understand what I want. So he protected me, which is super great. Instead of pushing me to a project as soon as possible. He gave me a chance to join some small project instead of the bigger one, which is a prototype project.

Since I didn't have the computer or any console when I was study sculpture at the Art University I have no idea how to make a video game, so I needed some time to learn how to make it. How the game is… how do you say, assembled or made. So I think I spent a few small prototype project, and then I think that was maybe one, no, almost two years and then all project is canceled.

James Tocchio: Oh, wow!

Keita Takahashi: But I was not the game designer. I was just a part of the artists, so it was not my fault. [laughs] Maybe. Maybe.

And then even my boss kind of feels so bad since I didn't ship any consumer product. He said ‘Hey Keita, do you want to join the other like a regular project.?’

But I couldn't decide if I want to join or not, and I just ask him. ‘Give me more time,’ and then the Katamari Damacy idea just came from… I just saw. I just came up with the idea. It was great timing. And then I had to present a pitch of the idea to my boss. And he said, ‘Oh, that may be cool.’

James Tocchio: Was this the same person that had sort of been guiding you through early days at the company?

Keita Takahashi: Yeah.

James Tocchio: That's really lucky to have someone like that.

Keita Takahashi: Yeah, I mean, I was just lucky. I just keep being lucky in this. I still don't, I still don't understand. I still don't believe that I have been working on video games since the start of my career. It's almost 20 years. It's crazy.

James Tocchio: And did you know that Katamari Damacy is in the Museum of Modern Art in New York City?

Keita Takahashi: Yeah, yeah, I know.

James Tocchio: Were you involved in that? Did they talk to you, or did you go there.

Keita Takahashi: I didn't go there, but the Moma asked Namco, when I was in the Namco studio. It's crazy.

James Tocchio: Do you look at that with pride, or is that something you don't think about?

Keita Takahashi: Mmm. I mean. It's hard to describe. I have two [thoughts on this]. Maybe the one is that I don't care. Another one is that yeah, just ignoring. Yeah.

James Tocchio: I understand. I've spoken with a lot of people who create things, and many of them are simply focused on the thing that they're creating. And they're not too worried about all of the extraneous aspects that surround it. They're just focused on the work. Does that sound like how you see yourself?

Keita Takahashi: Maybe I mean, I don't know what's the difference between art and video game. I still don't know what the definition of the video game is, as well. So if they just pick the Katamari as art, that's fine. But I don't care about the genre or categories, it's so stupid.

James Tocchio: You just want to make what you want to make, and if it resonates with people, then that's great.

Keita Takahashi: Yeah, if the people makes happy or smile with the game I made. That's, that's it.

James Tocchio: Are you a musician? Besides game development. [Takahashi is shaking his head incredulously. And smirking.] No, you don't play any instruments. I’m surprised because your games have such amazing music.

Keita Takahashi: Because I have amazing composer around me.

James Tocchio: Who composed the music, for To a T.

Keita Takahashi: My wife, Asuka [Sakai].

James Tocchio: That's wonderful. It's great music. My girls have been humming it for days. Do you play video games? Besides the ones that you're working on.

Keita Takahashi: No, no.

James Tocchio: It’s funny. I've talked to a lot of people that develop video games at a high level and many of them don't play video games.

Keita Takahashi: Oh, really.

James Tocchio: They're too busy making them, I think. They're just so focused on their work.

Keita Takahashi: I think so. But even when I was not busy I don't play video games.

James Tocchio: But surely you played games at some point.

Keita Takahashi: Yes. Of course. Yes. But in the art school, I think I stopped playing the video game because I realized that making something is more fun than just playing.

James Tocchio: Do you remember the first game that you ever played?

Keita Takahashi: Oh, the first one, I think that's a Japanese specific console. I forgot the name. It's a Cassette Vision. Maybe it's before the Famicom. No, yeah. Before the Famicom. I had a friend who had a lot of video game console. And it was called a Cassette Vision. Do you know that? Let me check, let me search.

James Tocchio: I'll have to look it up.

Keita Takahashi: It looks like an Atari.

James Tocchio: Okay.

Keita Takahashi: Oh! This! [Keita shows me the Cassette Vision.]

James Tocchio: Oh, Cassette Vision. I don’t know that one.

Keita Takahashi: Yeah, this is a Japanese.

James Tocchio: 1984. That was when I was born, you know.

Keita Takahashi: Oh, really. Oh, Super Cassette Vision, maybe this Super version was my 1st game. It was super simple.

James Tocchio: 1984, yeah, I would imagine. So let's talk a little bit about Namco and those early days again. When you pitched Katamari, was it difficult to get them to give you a team and funding, and all of that?

Keita Takahashi: So that, my boss, said that's gonna be difficult to use the regular path to get the green light. So he was working at the different department to teach students how to make a 3D model as an artist. The curriculum was making the game with them. So my boss was very smart. He picked my idea as a prototype game.

James Tocchio: I see.

Keita Takahashi: And then we hired some engineer who were almost fired from the company because, I don't know, I forgot the reason, but the other department want rid of them and we rescued the person, then used them as an engineer in the prototype project. So [the team was] the student, the artist, then an almost fired engineer, and then me as a very beginner, amateur, a no experience game designer. Then I think we had at least two professionals.

James Tocchio: To guide the ragtag group.

Keita Takahashi: Yeah, then I forgot how much time we spend to make a prototype but six months or five months. And we use the Nintendo [Game]Cube hardware, because I believe, for the engineer that was easier than PlayStation.

We made a prototype, then pitch to the company. The initial goal was to exhibit the game to some event. I forgot the name. But there's an art event. Then we put the game as a school project.

James Tocchio: I see.

Keita Takahashi: Yeah, then we show the game to the executive in the company. Also the other employees as well. It seems like they like the game a lot. So then my boss came again, then negotiate to the executives, but they said, I guess they could not spend a lot of money for such a new experimental game. So they wanted to use outsourcing company, not the Namco itself. But I really wanted to work inside of Namco team because they are more higher spec. But you know, it was better than nothing. So I just. I said, Okay, let me go to the outsourcing company. Namco is at the Yokohama, around Tokyo, and the outsourcing company was more West Side, in Osaka. So I moved to Osaka.

James Tocchio: What about when the sequel was made? Was Namco more more willing to spend some money on it after you'd proven a success.

Keita Takahashi: Yeah, I think so. But the reason I wanted to make Katamari was there's so many similar games, like even now there are so many similar games, but that’s 20 years ago.

Namco was making very same similar types of games, like a racing game, a shooting game, RPG, it's nothing new. They made a more unique game in 1980s or ‘90s. So I wanted to make a very unique game that only play, in the game like a… you can just drive a car, if you have a car, there's no point to play racing game, because you have a car right. You can play football. You don't need to play football game, right?

So I wanted to make a video game that only a video game can do. So making the sequel is not what I wanted, so the first time they asked me, I refused. But it seemed like they still wanted to make a sequel, even without me. Which also I hated.

So I decided, maybe just only one sequel. And then I leave after this. So yeah. I did it.

James Tocchio: Yeah. So you made the sequel with them, and then you became independent. You wanted to go see what else you could do, you're always looking for the next interesting thing, not just repeating what you've done.

Keita Takahashi: I think so. Yeah.

James Tocchio: Are you happy with how things have gone since then, with all the different projects that you've done?

Keita Takahashi: Of course not. I mean, I think that all developers are never happy about their games.

James Tocchio: I find that with many people who create things. I talk to a lot of writers as well. And we're just never happy. You finish something, and even if it's a success, it’s embarrassing. You don't want to look at it. You don't want to think about it. You want to just move on to the next thing and do better next time. So I think I understand.

Keita Takahashi: Yeah.

James Tocchio: You said you weren't content to be a 3D artist. You wanted to create a game of your own. That said, your background was 3D art and making models. When you were making Katamari, did you spend any time yourself creating character models in that game, or the models and objects? Or were you directing artists to do that kind of work.

Keita Takahashi: I did. Actually, I made The Prince model by myself. also, animation. I mean, I like to. I like modeling. I like the making picture. Of course I was. I like art.

But this was a video game company. That's a very huge chance to make a video game. So that's why I just set my goal. If I join the company, I should make my own game rather than just being the artist, because this is a video game company, not the artist company.

James Tocchio: I understand.

Keita Takahashi: That's it. [Takahashi shrugs.] Then I made it. Oh, that was so lucky.

James Tocchio: I find it very interesting how understated you are. You've created one of the best video games of all time, and you talk about it like, well, it's not a very big deal.

Keita Takahashi: Yeah. But I mean, it's hard to tell. It’s just a video game. Right?

James Tocchio: Yeah. Okay. I see where you're coming from. [I don’t.]

Well there’s a reason that I asked you about making character or object models. And that’s because some of the models in Katamari, for me personally, and I know other people have spoken about this before and written about this, and a lot of fans say this- it's almost as if every single 3D model in that game is special. There's something about them. Taken as individual components, they're all gorgeous. They're beautiful, they're charming. They're cute. They're funny. There's just some magic about each and every little object that you can roll up in that game. And so obviously, a lot of care and attention must have gone into that. So I was curious if you were sitting there for hours and days and weeks creating all these little creatures and objects and people and animals, or if you were more directing, saying, no, this cat needs to be cuter, or this mouse needs to not have legs and just roll around. So I was curious about the nuts and bolts of creating these games, I guess.

Keita Takahashi: Yeah. I think that all came from the spec of the PS2. Also the concept of the katamari, because we need to put tons of objects on the katamari ball. My understanding was the GPU was not so strong in the PS2, but we want to show a lot of objects as much as possible. So each single object would need to be very simple, low poly. and then, if they’re low poly then I know this is some decision for the art style, but for me, if it's low poly, then the texture shouldn't be very realistic. The texture also should be simple. Easy to understand.

James Tocchio: Right, yeah.

Keita Takahashi: I don't think it required a lot of time to get that direction of the art. I spoke to the art director, and he also agreed to that direction. I know many people love that simpleness and clean texture like. What… Minecraft.

James Tocchio: Yes. I think your designs are a little more charming than Minecraft. But I know what you're saying. Okay, let me ask specifically about one model. I think it was in the sequel? Your scuba diving cat? Do you remember the scuba diving cat [In the Katamari Damacy sequel We Love Katamari, there’s a stage which takes place mostly underwater and this stage contains a number of fun little low poly cats wearing low poly scuba masks and snorkels].

Keita Takahashi: Yes.

James Tocchio: Have you seen that the low poly scuba cat has been tattooed on people, and people are making it into T-shirts and all sorts of pins and key chains.

Keita Takahashi: What?! Really? No, no, no. I didn't know that.

James Tocchio: There's a lot of internet threads and memes and posts on social media of the snorkeling cat, where people are sharing their tattoos and their shirts and drawings.

Keita Takahashi: Oh, that's crazy!

James Tocchio: I wonder if you knew who created that particular model.

Keita Takahashi: I don’t remember.

James Tocchio: Yeah, that's hard to remember.

Keita Takahashi: I mean, we only had two level designer, including me. So either me or the other one made that.

James Tocchio: But that art style has followed you along in your career, though you say that it was originally brought about by technical limitations. But as technology has improved, you've maintained that similar sort of aesthetic. I know that simple design is actually extremely complicated. It's more difficult to design something simple than it is something super complex.

But do you think that sort of that aesthetic is a part of your identity now as a creator? Or is that just what you're drawn to you.

Keita Takahashi: Oh, I think I just like the simple design. I don't know, because of…. It's hard to tell why I like the simple style, or why I choose this style. I think I don't have any confidence about my drawing skill. I'm not good at realistic photo type of art, but I do like the manga, or just simply drawing like a picture book, or young children drawings. Maybe that's why.

James Tocchio: If you weren't a game designer, do you think you would be an artist making children's books, or something else?

Keita Takahashi: Yeah, the art school. So there was a in Japan, maybe only in Japan, that the Japan is very unique. I'm not sure, because I was not able to spend my time in other country. But it's not only Japan, I mean for me, the college time was four years. I thought this would be the last freedom for me before I go to the company.

James Tocchio: The real world.

Keita Takahashi: Yeah. So I have one big concern, which is. I like, make something I like. I also like drawing something. But then I'm in the sculpture department, which is very unnecessary stuff. So I had no idea how to earn the money after graduate to school. And also, yeah, I was not clear what I want to do. I  had this idea from way before I went to the art school. But I choose that because I like the art. I like making something. I spent four years to think about what I can do, what I want to be, what I want to make.

And the answer is super simple and stupid. But since I got the idea by myself, so that is very big to me. It's not something I steal from others, and it’s still precious and still stick to me even after graduate school, after like 20 or 30 years, which is make people smile. That was a very unforgettable moment. At the school I made a goat shaped flower pot, planter.

Yeah, you know this story.

James Tocchio: I've seen a picture of your goat. Yeah.

Keita Takahashi: Yeah, goat.

James Tocchio: I think I saw it on Twitter. I think you posted it. But tell me the story again.

Keita Takahashi: Yeah, yeah, yes.

So, every time in the arts college, you need to do like a presentation like a show and tell about stuff you made. So I did. I made a goat shaped flower pot or… planter. And for my presentation I just put the water on the water can, and then adding the water on the back of the goat, and the extra water [drained through] from the… how do you say this… boobs.

James Tocchio: The udder??

Keita Takahashi: Yeah, udder [laughing], but that stupid presentation makes the student or other professor laugh and smile. That was a, that was a moment for me. I think, “Oh, this is what I want to do! This is much nicer than like ‘Oh, this is beautiful and nice.’”

James Tocchio: Then is it fair to say your whole career has been an attempt to make people smile.

Keita Takahashi: Yeah, I think so. Also the other stuff. Other important stuff was I wanted to make a tool rather than art, because I saw the other students just throw away the stuff they made after the presentation, which I really hated. So if I make a tool, then I can keep using this, and I like that idea as well. So that's why I made a goat flower pot and other stuff, I made a low table that could be transformed to a robot.

James Tocchio: Oh, wow!

Keita Takahashi: I still have that in my house.

James Tocchio: Do you have the goat planter?

Keita Takahashi: No.

James Tocchio: Where did the goat go.

Keita Takahashi: Broken.

James Tocchio: Aw, well that does happen sometimes.

Keita Takahashi: Yeah. So making a tool and making people smile was my two biggest make a point, but the making people smile is more higher priority for me. So I don't know, if I was not being the game designer, maybe I could be a comedian or something [laughing].

Right: Keita, speaking to me from his garage studio.
Left: Me in my office, star-struck.

James Tocchio: Is your ultimate hope for To a T that it just makes people smile then?

Keita Takahashi: I think so. Yeah, that's it. I think I was cursed about the idea of interactivity. In doing the Namco, because I believe the interactivity is most highest priority, for the video game, because of the interaction is the key of the video games.

James Tocchio: Right.

Keita Takahashi: I don't know any other media that has interaction other than video games. So that's why I was making like a Katamari and Noby Noby; Katamari is rolling, Noby Noby is stretching and Wattam is connection and exploring. But after I finished Wattam I had a time to think about the video games, and I just noticed, “Oh, I could be happy and smile to watch the anime or manga, or just movie.” I thought, “Oh, I don't need any interaction. Just  consuming something can make me smile. Which is nice.” And I thought, “Oh, why, I got the curse from the interactivity.”

Also, I still didn't know what's the definition of the video game. I know there's so many genre or category inside of the video games. But there's no specific definition of what a video game is, because we don't need lose or win. But the video game is not only about the collection or fighting, or how do you say, solve the puzzle. Timing, press the timing in like a sound game music game, but there could be more. So I just this time for To a T I tried to ignore interactivity. I didn't put interactivity to the first priority.

I said, “More narrative and more like an unclear atmosphere.” How do you say, like a nice… nice vibe? Or mood?

James Tocchio: Vibe, okay. Yeah. Nice vibe.

Keita Takahashi: I know that I'm very unclear and abstract, but that's what I want to try to put into the game, because the current situation, the real world, our world is so… [mischievous smile] so nice, you know.

James Tocchio: Yeah, gotcha.

Keita Takahashi: So I wanted to make something very positive. Put the spotlight to our life, not a billionaire’s life.

James Tocchio: The story of To a T seems like it's going to focus on the main character’s struggles with being picked on for something that makes them different from other people. Now, I haven't played the whole game, so I don't know if that's where we're going with this, but that's what it seems like to me so far. Were you picked on as a kid in school.

Keita Takahashi: Yeah, yeah.

James Tocchio: Did that influence this game?

Keita Takahashi: Of course, that's a part of the reason I picked the student time or school time for the main scenario. Yeah. I was bullied between elementary and middle school. But somehow, I survived through that tough time very nicely, which is also another lucky [thing] for me, and I learned a lot of stuff from that hard time. So, at this moment, when I look back at the past, that was a nice experience for me, but I know when I was younger that was very tough.

Maybe the reason I was bullied was I was fat, very fat. So, if there's a t-posed stuck person in your class… Different from people. Same thing.

James Tocchio: I'm very interested to see where the story goes. You're talking about interactivity and you were saying that you're not sure what defines a game, and I think I agree with what you were saying, but I think the difference between video games and other media is not just about interactivity. With a game there’s a deeper connection much of the time, you experience something that no other media can really help you experience when you are sort of inhabiting that character. And so I know when I'm playing To a T, and I'm experiencing classmates that aren't being nice, that brings in more emotion than if I was just watching it in a TV show or a movie because you're part of the character, and you're part of the world, and you're the one that’s got your arm stuck in a T pose. So I'm very interested to see where that goes, and I want to play it with my daughters and see what they take away from it as well.

Keita Takahashi: Yeah, thank you. Also, I'm worried. But just worry. Concerned how people will react to it.

James Tocchio: Yeah, that must be stressful. I read an interview that you did with somebody that I follow, and they were playing your new game, and they were talking to you, and I think they said something like, “It's very weird,” or “You made another weird game!” And your response was to look a little disappointed and say something like “I was trying to make a normal one this time.”

Keita Takahashi: [Takahashi smiles.] I mean, yes, different definitely, because it looks so normal compared to the other my games.

James Tocchio: Normal? Maybe. I mean, there's a dancing giraffe, you know.

Keita Takahashi: The reason why we have the giraffe in the game is just my pick. But you know oh, this person looks like a giraffe or elephant. It’s imagination.

James Tocchio: Is To a T coming to Nintendo Switch or Switch 2?

Keita Takahashi: Yeah, I hope.

James Tocchio: You hope? Okay. But there are no plans right now?

Keita Takahashi: We have plans. But no time to spend for Switch or Switch 2 yet.

James Tocchio: I want to know why you made Crankin’ Time Travel Adventure so difficult.

Keita Takahashi: Oh, because people love these hard game. Maybe that's my mistake.

James Tocchio: No, no! I love the game, it’s just really challenging!

Keita Takahashi: I mean, yeah, I don't play the video games, but people really love difficult, like a tough game, like From Software game. So I just wanted to prove I could also make a difficult.

James Tocchio: I was surprised though. I got the Play Date, and I was like, “Wow, a game from Keita Takahashi. This is great!” And I thought it was going to be this fun, easy, cute little thing, and I got maybe 10 stages in, or something, and it just gets so tough! Brutal! You have to be pixel perfect on this.

Keita Takahashi: Yeah, yeah, yeah. [Keita is laughing and nodding, looking a bit embarrassed.] I should… I should have more tuning, doesn't it?

James Tocchio: Okay, when you think of your career in game development, what’s the best part of the job?

Keita Takahashi: The best part of the job...

[30 second pause]

This… Hmm.

Let's see, it's a difficult question. Hmm.

[20 second pause]

Best part of the… Oh! I like the moment.

Sorry. This is super super tiny stuff, but I really like the moment when we see stupid bug that makes us super stupid, awesome.

James Tocchio: You. You like finding bugs.

Keita Takahashi: Uh huh. Super unexpected, but also super silly. Bug. Yeah.

James Tocchio: Silly bugs, so something breaks the game, or…

Keita Takahashi: I think.

James Tocchio: Like when a bug breaks the game?

Keita Takahashi: Yes. Which nobody will ever see in the product, but we can see it.

James Tocchio: Okay. And do you record them, and save them for your own pleasure?

Keita Takahashi: Yeah. Yes. To share with the teammates, of course.

James Tocchio: That's so funny. And how many bugs have you found.

Keita Takahashi: It's a lot. At least a thousand.

James Tocchio: Wow, at least a thousand. So that's your favorite part, and you've had the pleasure of enjoying it a thousand times.

[Pause.]

Keita Takahashi: [Sighs] It's not true, I think. [Laughs]

James Tocchio: That's great. Can you think of what is the toughest part of your job, or the least favorite?

[Takahashi pauses to think again.]

James Tocchio: Is it interviews?

Keita Takahashi: [Laughs] I don't. I don't want be so serious about this, but the getting the money by making the video game itself is amazing, and a miracle for me. Right. I'm not a teacher. I'm not a doctor. I'm not making any necessary product. But I can get money and live. Which is great.

I'm sorry, so serious, stupid answer but sometimes I feel bad being a game developer, because I should be more nice for the earth and people, because I know I happy to see the people making smile and be happy when they play my games, or when they play other games as well, which is great. But playing video games requires many conditions, like you need a TV, and you need hardware and internet, also a couch and electricity and a house, whatever. So much stuff you need to buy. And then finally, you get the game, which are tons of effort and tons of financial requirement, which feels so bad.

But if I was a musician or something, maybe I could just go to a public space and to sing or play the guitar, and people just pass through and maybe they could listen to my voice randomly, but that's still maybe giving some impression, which doesn't need any commitment. I feel jealous about musicians or other performers.

James Tocchio: So you wish you could just give this away. You could just make people happy without any requirement from them?

Keita Takahashi: Yeah, Yeah, that's one of the reasons I wanted to create the playground.

James Tocchio: Yeah, I read about your playground project.

Keita Takahashi: Yeah, because it's free. I know it's not free, because it's based on like a tax.

James Tocchio: Yes, but I know what you're saying. It's there and anyone can enjoy it whenever they want without having to pay or do anything extra.

Keita Takahashi: Yeah, so maybe I need to be a billionaire and make my own playground. Then make it open to the public.

James Tocchio: Yeah. So we just need to sell a lot of To a T.

Keita Takahashi: Yes, please.

James Tocchio: And then you can give it all away and make-

Keita Takahashi: Yeah.

James Tocchio: -all sorts of free public works.

Keita Takahashi: Yeah. Then I'm gonna be homeless or living at the playground that I made.

James Tocchio: Okay, well, that sounds beautiful in a way.

Keita Takahashi: Yeah, I think so.

James Tocchio: Is there anything that you'd like to make sure we mention or or include in this in this, write up.

Keita Takahashi: No. But yeah, please support us. Yes, the game will be funny and funnier than everyone expect so hope people like it.

James Tocchio: I think people are going to like it.

Keita Takahashi: Yeah, at least your daughters.

James Tocchio: I told them that I was going to be talking with you when I picked them up from school and the first thing they asked was, “When is To a T coming out?”

Keita Takahashi: Okay, wait. Did they play the game, or did they just watch.

James Tocchio: They both wanted to play it, so they both played it.

Keita Takahashi: Oh!

James Tocchio: All the way through, two times each over the last two days. They love it, and I think it's very well designed. You don't need me to tell you this, but it's very well designed

Keita Takahashi: That's a good feedback from the play test, though. Thank you. That's good to know.

James Tocchio: Okay, we’re approaching an hour, so I’m going to wrap things up. But again, I want to thank you for the opportunity to chat with you. I've been enjoying everything that you've done for the last 20 years. So this is such a treat for me, and I know that my readers are going to love it, too.

Keita Takahashi: Great. Thank you so much.

James Tocchio: Oh, thank you so much truly appreciated, and have a great rest of the day.

Keita Takahashi: You, too. Thank you.

Interview Transcript: Kazuyuki Yamai, April 2025

In February, 2025, I re-played one of my favorite games on the Nintendo Wii, Trauma Center: Second Opinion. A remake of the original Nintendo DS game, Second Opinion improves on the original in every way, and as I rolled credits, I felt the familiar urge to share my love for the game in the pages of Retro Gamer Magazine. I pitched an article to the editors, and though they were interested, they said that the piece would not be possible unless I was able to secure an interview with one of its creators.

I reached out to SEGA and Atlus in hope that we could arrange something. That very day, the company announced a new remaster of another of my favorite games; the PlayStation 2 Shin Megami Tensei spin-off Devil Summoner: Raidou Kuzunoha vs the Soulless Army. This shifted my entire tact. Instead of seeking an interview around the classic Trauma Center, I asked to chat with someone about Devil Summoner, which was suddenly a timely topic.

With the help of the incredible people at Sega Europe, we were able to quickly arrange an interview with Kazuyuki Yamai, the director of both the original Raidou and the new remastered game. My comprehensive article on the original PlayStation 2 game appears in Retro Gamer Magazine issue 273, with a supplementary box-out on the new game. In that piece, I have included portions of my interview with Yamai-san, however, due to space and scope of focus, much of the original interview was not included.

Here, then, is the full transcript of my Q&A with Kazuyuki Yamai, game director at Atlus.

---

James: With RAIDOU Remastered set to launch in just a few weeks, how is the team feeling at this moment? Is there a sense of excitement, anticipation, or perhaps some nerves as the release day approaches?

Yamai-san: The entire team is deeply moved by the enthusiastic reception that far exceeded our expectations when the title was announced. Our greatest challenge now is whether we can maintain that level of excitement until the release date, and that date can’t come fast enough (laughs). We have kept a keen eye on social media and have enjoyed the fun posts everyone has shared about our game.

Myself included, it feels as though everyone on the team is developing the game not just to complete it, but because we are eagerly looking forward to the moment the game reaches users’ hands. We have created this game because we want to bring joy to everyone and because we truly want to hear your feedback.

James: Given ATLUS' growing global reputation through popularity of titles like Persona and Metaphor, how would you introduce Raidou to newer fans who may be more accustomed to your recent releases?

Yamai-san：One of the key features of RAIDOU Remastered is that it is a mystery drama where the player takes on the role of a named character, Raidou Kuzunoha, and aims to solve supernatural cases. I believe this aspect will feel especially fresh and enjoyable for those who have played other ATLUS games.

James: Having previously directed SMT Nocturne HD Remaster, how has the experience of reimagining and remastering a game you helped create nearly two decades ago influenced you both personally and technically?

Yamai-san: With remasters, unlike with new titles, we cannot simply change the content to suit the developers’ circumstances—such as plans, technology, or development timelines—because the original version already exists.

There are also fans already of the original, who carry with them many good memories of the game and eagerly await the remaster.

When remastering a title that I developed myself, I first try to recall the ideal vision I had for the game—what I wanted it to be like—back when I developed the original. I then carefully compare that vision with the fans’ memories as I make decisions about the game’s specifications and before I move forward with development.

Because of this, I feel that developing the remaster has helped the staff not only to improve their technical skills as developers, but also to cultivate a more user-oriented perspective. In other words, we have become more conscious of balancing creativity and service.

That’s why, compared to “SMT Nocturne HD Remaster,” we made even more changes to RAIDOU Remastered from a service-oriented perspective this time.

James: When modernizing classic titles like Raidou, how do you strike the balance between introducing fresh gameplay mechanics and preserving the original spirit? Could you share an example of a challenging decision you faced during this process?

Yamai-san: First, we began by exploring the true essence of what made the original version so appealing, and we discussed this thoroughly with the team. We decided to firmly preserve those core elements, but also change anything else that no longer fit with the times. For example, since Raidou as a character has a cool and mysterious charm, we felt it was acceptable to add new combat actions and mechanics—even if it meant deviating from the original—as long as we didn’t stray from that core appeal. On the other hand, we were careful to avoid making him overly talkative or chatty, as that would fundamentally change his personality.

The team members continued to brainstorm and discuss ideas without giving up until the very end. I am very proud of what the team achieved. We hope everyone enjoys the game when we launch!

James: RAIDOU Remastered introduces several gameplay improvements, such as a reworked demon capture system that moves away from the rapid button-mashing of the original (my thumb thanks you!!). Which updates do you believe will be most significant for longtime fans who played the game in the 2000s?

Yamai-san: Some of the major changes include the large-scale update to the battle system, the fact that you no longer encounter enemies everywhere—even in town—and the increased number of demons, which has made demon fusion more interesting.

Thanks to these updates, I believe players can now fully enjoy the world of Taisho Year 20 and its fascinating characters without being hindered by the frustrations that existed in the original version.

James: With the new inclusion of voice acting in RAIDOU Remastered, what unique challenges and opportunities did you encounter when integrating this feature into a game that originally didn’t have it?

Yamai-san: Well, there was the issue of deciding on the proper accent for each word, and also, since Japanese uses kanji, it’s interesting in that— even if you can’t read the character out loud—Japanese people often feel like they understand the meaning just from its shape. However, we were shocked to discover that in the original version, the readings for certain kanji weren’t always clearly decided. This happened quite a few times.

Of course, we were always concerned that adding voice acting might detract from the memories fans have of the original version that they cherish so much. In reality, the English and Japanese voice actors were extremely talented, so we were fortunate to have achieved both a naturalness that feels as if the game had voice acting from the beginning, and an increased sense of drama brought by the addition of voices.

James: Raidou’s unique setting in 1930s Japan and its blend of modernity versus tradition, combined with a detective protagonist, made it stand out when I first played it. Are you personally drawn to mystery and detective narratives? Who is your favorite fictional detective, and what draws you to their story?

Yamai-san: Personally, I enjoy autobiographies, biographies, and documentaries. Of course, I also love mystery novels. For those who love reading, there’s no greater joy than knowingly falling into an author’s narrative traps and being toyed with by the story.

My favorite detective is Kosuke Kindaichi, who appears in the works of the Japanese author Seishi Yokomizo.

Yokomizo often sets his mysteries not in big cities, but in closed, rural village societies where bizarre crimes unfold. At a glance, stories with these settings can easily become simple, gloomy or distasteful tales, but the introduction of Kindaichi—a charming character with both a goofy, human side and keen powers of observation—makes the world of those stories truly captivating.

By giving proper depth to the characters, even a dark story can become something that lingers in the audience’s hearts without simply being dreary. Yokomizo’s approach to world-building in this way has been a great inspiration to me.

James: What was your favorite video game of 2024, and what elements of it resonated with you?

Yamai-san: Since development of RAIDOU Remastered was in its final stages in 2024, I honestly don't remember much from that year...

I remember coming home late at night and often playing my Nintendo Switch. I’m not sure if it’s available overseas, but I played "Blaster Master Zero Trilogy Meta Fight Chronicle" and "Retro Game Challenge 1+2 Replay" all the way to the end.

As for today’s flashy visuals and effects, we can fully rely on the talented designers at ATLUS, as I personally tend to play retro games and more fundamental titles to keep myself from losing sight of the essence of gaming.

Although it’s not a retro game, "Stellar Blade"—which inevitably draws attention for its character designs—actually struck me as an action game that doesn’t lose sight of what’s essential.

James: Outside of the studio, how do you relax and recharge? What hobbies or activities help you unwind during the long game development process?

Yamai-san: As you pointed out, game development takes place over a long period of time. From my experience, I’ve learned that what’s essential is “not losing an objective perspective.” When you spend a long time working on the same game, it becomes difficult to judge whether it’s good or bad. That’s why developers need to deliberately find ways to keep an objective view of what they’re creating. To maintain this objectivity, it’s important to recharge and take breaks.

In my case, I repeat cycles of deeply immersing myself in thinking about my title—fully engaging with the project—and then deliberately distancing myself, entrusting things to other staff members for a period of time, in order to preserve my objectivity. This period of leaving things to others acts as my time to recharge, during which I immerse myself in my hobbies, such as making music or reading books.

I also go sightseeing and travel with my family. And I make it a point to engage in discussions and exchange ideas with people from other companies and industries over drinks, so I can be exposed to new perspectives.

James: Like many of ATLUS’ games, Raidou features an amazing blend of work from a number of iconic talents (I’m thinking of the character designs of Kazuma Kaneko and the music of Shoji Meguro). How do you ensure that the unique artistic and musical sensibilities they contributed are maintained during the remastering process?

Yamai-san: This may overlap with what I mentioned earlier about the "essence of appeal," but if the original version already fully displayed its artistic qualities to the users, I try not to make unnecessary changes.

On the other hand, if I feel that those qualities weren’t sufficiently expressed, I intentionally make improvements to establish the artistic vision that should have been realized. I have great respect for Mr. Kaneko and Mr. Meguro, and I am always mindful of respecting not only their work but also the memories and feelings of the fans who supported the original version.

James: With the global game industry facing layoffs and studio closures, many Japanese studios—including ATLUS—pride themselves on long-term talent retention. How do you think this stability has contributed to Atlus' success, and what are your thoughts on the benefits of retaining veteran creators for decades?

Yamai-san: As someone in the same industry, it’s never easy to hear news about layoffs. I think many dev teams in Japan have been fortunate in this regard. That’s because, rather than simply pursuing larger development scales as hardware specs improved, we had both an environment and a customer base that allowed us to continue focusing on the fundamental essence of gameplay.

At ATLUS I believe the presence of a veteran staff has allowed that approach—striving for the essence of gameplay, aiming for unique game content, the so-called “ATLUS spirit”—lives on within the company. And since we constantly bring in new developers as well, that spirit is always being updated to fit the modern age.

James: I once interviewed a legendary game creator at Nintendo, and was stunned when they told me their favorite snack for powering through late night game development. Now I ask all of my interviewees this question: What is your favorite food or drink for working at the office?

Yamai-san: That’s an interesting question! I’m really curious to know who that creator is (laughs). And of course, I also can’t do without snacks while I work.

I have a big sweet tooth, and I especially love "Meiji Essel Super Cup" ice cream. Drizzling some strong coffee over the vanilla flavor in the cup makes it incredibly delicious. I also regularly eat "Doramocchi Anko & Whip," which is sold at Lawson (a convenience store chain in Japan), to enjoy a touch of elegance while working after lunch.

James: In 2013, ATLUS became a subsidiary of SEGA, and while I know that ATLUS has total autonomy, and their own catalogue of amazing games, it is fun for fans of both SEGA and ATLUS to dream about the studios working together. With this hypothetical scenario in mind, are there any SEGA series or games that you would like to work on with your team at Atlus? As a fan myself, I have daydreamed about ATLUS creating a new Skies of Arcadia or Phantasy Star.

Yamai-san: As you said, if we’re talking about “ATLUS, the RPG company,” then games like “Eternal Arcadia” (Skies of Arcadia) or “Phantasy Star” might be easier for us to develop. However, in reality, SEGA probably feels a deeper attachment to those IPs, so in my opinion, I’m not sure if ATLUS would be the right choice.

Personally (even if it’s not particularly wanted...), I would love to see a complete consumer ports of “SEGA Rally 2.” Since SEGA Rally 2 was a launch title for the Dreamcast, I remember that it experienced a lot of slowdown, perhaps because the team wasn’t used to the hardware yet. Incidentally, back then I was involved in developing “Maken X” at ATLUS.

James: I love all of the SMT games and their spin-offs, so I have a personal request that whatever game you work on next, can you somehow include a port of the Atlus game “Jack Bros.” from the Virtual Boy? What about Maken X? Can’t you imagine Raidou sitting in the Narumi Detective Agency playing these on a magical game console?

Yamai-san: You mean, like including it as an in-game game, similar to SEGA’s "Like a Dragon"? I think that would be very interesting! I do have some concerns about how much of "Hee-Ho in the Maze (“Jack Bros.”)" (Virtual Boy)'s fun could be recreated on current hardware without stereoscopic 3D support… (I can’t help but feel sorrow that Nintendo 3DS is no longer active.)

"Maken X" is also a title I have fond memories of being involved in (and I also worked on its spinoff, the PS2 version "Maken Shao"), and since it’s also an action game like "RAIDOU Remastered," if "RAIDOU" becomes a hit and a sequel is made, having an in-game game is a fun idea to pursue as well (laughs).

In any case, I’m truly grateful that you continue to support our old games even now!

James: Finally, with this interview appearing in Retro Gamer Magazine, what are some of your all-time favorite retro games, and what about them continues to inspire you?

Yamai-san: "Super Mario Bros." has been my textbook for game design ever since I was in elementary school.

"Metroid" is a showcase of ideas to keep gameplay from ever becoming boring.

"Ridge Racer," with its soundtrack representing a genre that hadn’t existed in the game industry until then, was my senior mentor that taught me it’s okay to draw inspiration from other entertainment fields.

The "MSX version of The Goonies" was a cautionary example that taught me how trying to pursue a port that’s just not meant to be can only lead to disappointing players (laughs).

Interview Transcript: Dylan Cuthbert, March 2025

Dylan Cuthbert was one of the first western developers to work for Nintendo, where, with colleagues from Argonaut Software, he helped create Star Fox for the SNES. He went on to work at Sony for a time, then founded his own studio Q-Games, who created the PixelJunk game series. They’re currently hard at work on Dreams of Another, a superbly stylish and interesting game coming soon.

For Retro Gamer number 271, I interviewed Dylan about his long and colorful career. Due to scope of focus and space, some of our interview did not appear in the magazine. Here is the unedited transcript of my conversation with Dylan.

---

James: Thank you for taking the time to chat. Before I launch into the interview, I’d like to take a moment to thank you for your work, and the many ways that you and your various colleagues have contributed to my life. I hope you know that your work has brought (and continues to bring) much happiness to millions of people.

I did not want to miss the opportunity to thank you personally. 

For those who may not be familiar, can you please tell us briefly about how you broke into the game industry, and how you managed to become so closely linked with Nintendo? 

Dylan: I saw an ad in the back of a magazine for a job at Argonaut Software, I think it was Personal Computer Weekly, while I was still at school, applied for that, quit school and began working there. One of the first things I worked on was a Z80 emulator that ran on the Amiga, which I knocked up to emulate what we imagined the GameBoy’s architecture was like. It wasn’t too far wrong, and so gave us a head start when we began hacking the real hardware to load up our programs onto it. I developed a small 3D demo called Eclipse which at some point got shown to Nintendo during CES in Vegas. About two weeks later I was flown over with Jez, my boss, to show that to Nintendo HQ in Kyoto. They liked what they saw and signed a deal to develop it into a full game in collaboration with them. To get 3D up and running on such a system I drew upon my experience programming the ZX Spectrum while I was at school. 

(NOTE: Speak on whatever you like, but  I am particularly interested in X, for the GameBoy, and the story of how that game came to be: reverse engineering the GameBoy hardware, creating a 3D engine for such a rudimentary game system, and how that caught the attention of Nintendo and led to SO MUCH later on.) 

James: During your career, you’ve worked with some truly legendary people in the games industry. To name a few from your early days at Nintendo, I’m thinking of Shigeru Miyamoto, Yoshio Sakamoto, the inventor of the GameBoy, Gunpei Yokoi, and many others. Can you talk about the ways that working with such immense personalities in gaming has helped or altered the way that you make games, and I’m wondering if you can think of a particular lesson or experience that you’ve carried with you through your long and impressive career?

Dylan: Miyamoto, Sakamoto, “Hip” Tanaka (now nicknamed Chip Tanaka), Yokoi, Izushi, Totaka (Totakeke), were all instrumental in my early years and I really enjoyed working with them all. They helped settle me into the Nintendo way of making games, which was very different to the way in the UK at the time. The games industry in the UK was still very much a bedroom industry, but here was Nintendo HQ where they had a large complex of buildings and lots of very busy people bustling around. The scale was incredibly different.

Sakamoto helped me understand that we shouldn’t make games too hard, not everyone was as hardcore a gamer as we were. Miyamoto taught me how to re-analyse a feature, and to remove if it just doesn’t fit. No matter how much you are attached to an idea, you need to let it go and move on if it just isn’t working.

James: The Nintendo composer Kazumi Totaka, who created the soundtracks for such games as WaveRace 64, Animal Crossing, Wii Sports, some Zelda games, etc., has incorporated into every one of his games an infamous hidden tune called “Totaka’s Song,” and the first appearance of this hidden song was in your GameBoy game X. Did you know about this when the game first released? When did you first learn of Totaka’s Song? 

Dylan: I knew about the hidden song and secret area of the game of course (I programmed it), but I don’t think even he realised that this would be a running meme in a lot of his games, because of course, it was the first. It was just a fun little melody he had knocking around and we had a fun little secret we needed something for.

James: Have you hidden anything into your own games over the years, similar to Totaka’s Song? Is there a Cuthbert signature that has yet to be discovered?

Dylan: In X I included a cheat code, it’s not really a signature, I simply formed the word ST-A-R-B-U-R-ST from the keys of the GameBoy and if you type that while you are in the pause screen it will jump you to the end credit sequence of the game. (which has another great soundtrack by Totaka)

James: Star Fox, which you programmed, has been well-covered, but I’m wondering if you can talk a bit about this game. What is your most prominent memory of creating Star Fox with Argonaut and the people at Nintendo?

Dylan: Going for McVities chocolate biscuits at the local convenience store at 3 in the morning is one of my best memories. The schedule was a bit tight and we were waiting for final bug reports. Miyamoto and everyone else were there, and Miyamoto had a hankering for his favorite student-era snack, which happened to be McVities chocolate biscuits, which, weirdly enough, were sold in Japan back then. Sadly you can’t find them here anymore.

James: I recently interviewed Giles Goddard for Retro Gamer #266, where we discussed Stunt Race FX, specifically. I don’t think you worked on Stunt Race FX, correct? Would this be the time period during which you were working on Star Fox 2?

Dylan: I was working on Star Fox 2 during that period. In order to help teach the staff at Nintendo more about 3D, we split the team into two and added a few Japanese programmers. Giles was working in a little area adjacent to the Star Fox one.

James: Star Fox 2 was infamously canceled in 1995, despite being a finished game. At that time, was it disappointing to have worked on such a big-name game only for it to be locked away in Nintendo’s vault? And did you have any thoughts or feelings when the game was finally released with the SNES Mini hardware in 2019?

Dylan: Yes, although I was ready for a new adventure at that point so it didn’t phase me too much. I do wish it had been released but at the same time, the PlayStation had just launched and was obviously far superior at 3D graphics, so I wouldn’t have liked our game to be compared to that. I was very happy the game did finally get released!

Star Fox 3D was essentially a remake, rather than a port or remaster. Here my daughter is about to play.

James: After your time at Nintendo, you moved on to work with Sony. Can you talk a bit about this time period?    

Dylan: I joined PlayStation in the US, just a few months after the PlayStation had launched over there and began working on “Captain Blasto” which eventually became simply “Blasto”. That was quite a big cultural difference to the UK and Japan and I enjoyed American life immensely. I did find that the hours were much longer and harder than Nintendo’s, with a lot more pressure on milestone dates. Nintendo didn’t set dates until a game felt like it was ready, which led to more creativity and experimentation.

James: Do you have any interesting memories around your time working on Blasto, a somewhat overlooked action platformer which featured the voice talents of Phil Hartman? (Note: I loved this game)

Dylan: The team, which was a mix of Brits and Americans, was a blast. We all had very strong personalities so there were a lot of clashes, but at the same time, we were all young and that’s the kind of thing that keeps you on your toes, and even with tight schedules we pulled out all the stops to be as creative as possible. Blasto was a great 3D engine, with even individual polygons in the world having little scripted programs attachable to them. The PlayStation was a fun machine to develop for.

James: Broadly speaking, what has it been like to live and work in Japan for so long?

Dylan: I’m still loving it. I did enjoy my time in the US but nothing beats Kyoto I think. It just has such an eclectic mix of ancient and modern, classic and contemporary. It also has incredible food, and quite a cosmopolitan feel. It’s larger in population than Manchester yet still maintains a tight smaller town feel because of its density and because of the mountains and rivers that are nearby.

James: I’m wondering as a personal aside, likely not to be featured in the interview, but you were working in the industry at the time of the Dreamcast. I’m curious if you had any interest in that hardware, or Sega at large?

Dylan: I kept an eye on it, but never had a chance to develop for it. I was a big fan of games such as Daytona and Virtua Racer from a few years before then, and of course Crazy Taxi and the Harley Davidson game that preceded that. I just never really got the opportunity.

James: After working at Sony, you founded Q-Games in 2001. What was it like to go independent at that time?

Dylan: Since I was a kid I had always wanted to make my own games studio, it was like a standard dream for bedroom coders in the early 1980s, and one I managed to realise. The PlayStation 2 had just come out and I had just released a game for it (Ape Escape 2001) and I was ready to move back to Kyoto. At the time I had built up quite a name for myself within PlayStation so I decided it would be the right time to take the gamble. I took my idea to Akira Sato, one of the VPs, and he encouraged me and even set up an initial R&D contract to get us going (something I hadn’t asked for).

James: One of the first games that Q-Games developed was Star Fox Command. What was it like returning to Star Fox after a decade? And then later you directed Star Fox 64 3D, which is one of the best ports of any game that I’ve played on any system. What was it like to go from a programmer on the first game, to Director on this version?

Dylan: Nintendo approached us after we had taken a few ideas for different games to them a year or two earlier, even developing one of them, called “Digidrive”. They felt we were just about the right size (15 ppl) to take on something like a mobile version of Star Fox, especially considering my involvement in the first two installments.

I enjoyed being the director, and working with Imamura in the role of producer was a great experience. The experimentation and brainstorming was a lot of fun.

Star Fox 64 3D was a great project, I hesitate to call it a port because we actually had to re-work it a lot, re-modeling and re-texturing the entire game in the process.

James: I’d like to talk about PixelJunk. The series began with PixelJunk Racers, followed by the amazing tower defense game, PixelJunk Monsters, then Eden and Shooter, SideScroller, and 4am. Each of these games has such a unique presentation and philosophy, and it seems that the entire series is one of experimentation. Can you talk a bit about how this all came about? 

Dylan: We were working behind the scenes on the PS3, developing the XMB interface and the music visualisers, when there was mention that there would be an online store available on the PS3 where people could buy games that were download-only and that this would open up the doors for smaller companies like Q to develop and publish their own games on the platform. So we signed up immediately for that, and because the PS3 was the first system that supported 1080p HDMI output I decided to re-visit 2D gaming and pull upon all my memories from childhood, but this time with a full range of decent colours and pixel perfect high resolution, that’s why “hd” is hidden in the PixelJunk logo.

Hand model = my older daughter <3

James: PixelJunk Eden, in particular, struck a chord with me. The blend of music and simple but meditative and interesting game design reminds me of such games as REZ and Lumines. How did Eden game come to be, how did you end up working with Tomohisa Kuramitsu (Baiyon), and what are your feelings toward this game?

Dylan: From the beginning of the series I planned that the third title should be “artsy fartsy” in some way, more of an experimental title, and I was looking for a local artist who might be interested in collaborating on something like that. Some friends mentioned that there was a local DJ who was an artist and was also really interested in getting into the games industry in some way. I then met him by accident at a christmas party nearby, realised he was the guy who some people had mentioned and asked him to bring in his art so we could take a look at it. He brought in a bunch of crazy looking art, and something about one piece which looked like ink dripped plants caught my imagination - it reminded me of an old ZX Spectrum game I loved called Bugaboo the Flea. This got me thinking about how that game could be melded with modern looking art like that and PixelJunk Eden was born. Baiyon was a musician too so it really helped cement the whole mix of art, music and gameplay together.

James: Were you ever worried that the PixelJunk games would be poorly received due to their unusual styles? 

Dylan: I just assumed everyone was like me and likes to be surprised and inspired by different things all the time. After making many more games, I realise that many people prefer more of the same thing over and over again, but I just can’t cater to them, I have to be looking for something new and interesting to do.

James: Does Q-Games own the rights to the PixelJunk games? Is there any possibility that a collection of the games could be distributed as a physical release?

Dylan: Yes, all the PixelJunk games’ rights are held by Q-Games. I’m not sure we’d do a physical release now as some of the games are old, but I don’t rule out returning to some of the entries in the series at some time in the future.

James: What is the future of PixelJunk?

Dylan: We have a brand new PixelJunk title we will be announcing very soon, directed by Baiyon. It’s nothing like PixelJunk Eden so keep an eye out for that!

James: Is it true that Q-Games designed the Sony XMB (Xross Media Bar content management UI)? And the LiveArea UI for PS Vita? Can you tell me a bit about this?

Dylan: We collaborated with the Sony Design Center on the Sony XMB, developing its look for the PS3. We also worked on the visuals and UI for the Vita too yes, including the flip page effect. Our crowning achievement was getting the Earth visualiser into the PS3 though, we really enjoyed making that one.

James: What is it like to work at Q-Games? Do you have any advice for people who want to work in game development?

Dylan: At Q you need to be willing to brainstorm and collaborate in sometimes very painful ways, this all goes back to the Miyamoto method of game design. Sometimes we need to re-work ideas completely if they aren’t working. This is seen as part of the process here and it can be very different at other companies I feel. When we develop a feature for a game, we take a hard critical look at it and give it a thorough test, and if it doesn't click, we re-work it. My motto is “if something needs to be done, something needs to be done” and excuses don’t cut it, because as Miyamoto is famously quoted as saying “A delayed game is eventually good, but a rushed game is forever bad.”, so we’d all better do what needs to be done to make our game the best.

James: In 2021, Sony closed down Japan Studio, their in-house game studios which created some of the company’s best-loved experimental and smaller games for nearly 30 years (I think of Patapon, Puppeteer, LocoRoco, Gravity Rush, EchoChrome, and so many more). Do you think that there’s less appetite for experimental and smaller scale games within the big game companies these days? What do you think this means for the game industry? Does it mean anything? Do Indie companies simply have more room to run? Please elaborate if possible.

Dylan: I think this was a huge mistake by PlayStation as it is this exact genre of games that brings in new gamers to the platform, and it is this genre that is missing. The success of a game like Astrobot shows that games that experiment can do well, and some of the games you’ve listed up were huge hits such as LocoRoco. By closing down that studio they have lost a generation of Japanese developers.

James: In 2016, you directed The Tomorrow Children, which I feel was under-appreciated at the time. Can you discuss the development of this game? The visuals are stunning, and I know that a lot of technology went into creating this title. 

Dylan: We developed our own 3D engine from scratch for this title as we wanted to utilize the full Compute power of the PS4. We took renders from a tool called Octane Render that would take 10-20 seconds to complete, looked at them, and tried to work out ways we could get a similar look, but at a proper frame rate. We came across a technology called Cascaded Voxel Cone Ray Tracing in a little paper from Siggraph that looked like, maybe, it had promise, even though no-one had got it running faster than a few frames a second at that point.

Over a couple of years we fleshed out that technology and we got it performant, squeezing every single last cycle of power out of the Compute pipeline that we could find. It gave us effects such as multiple bounces of light, sub-surface scattering, reflections and semi-translucency, all with a dynamic world, not a static one.

James: In 2022, Q-Games secured the rights to The Tomorrow Children and re-released it. Was this a personal goal of yours? 

Dylan: Yes, I worked for years to get the IP given back to us after the game was shut down many years ago. It was frustrating to have a game that many people had enjoyed, and for which the average playtime was in the hundreds of hours for, just removed like that.

Because the technology was original the game looks just as good today as it did back then.

James: You have been involved in the creation of more than 35 games beginning in the late 1980s. As technology has advanced over this time, video games have undergone transformative change, becoming more ambitious, immersive, and incorporating stunning technology which was literally the stuff of dreams when you began your career. 

If you could go back and remake any of your older games using today’s technology, which would you choose, and can you share why?

Dylan: The original Star Fox would be fun to go back to I think. Also, something like PixelJunk Shooter could be very interesting if revisited in 3D with 3D fluids, but right now games are very expensive to make, so we have to balance funding with our lofty goals. Another one I would like to re-visit is PixelJunk 4am, that was just a little too ahead of its time and because it used the Move controller it was limited too much right from the get-go.

James: Would you ever like to revisit one of your older games in VR? Do you have any interest in VR in any capacity?

Dylan: I think there are still opportunities for some fun experiences in VR, we have developed a number of scrapped ideas for VR over the years and of course we launched Dead Hungry in the early days. So I don’t rule it out, but I think the market is difficult to read and I don’t want to make a game that people don’t discover or get to play.

James: You were given a Special Thanks credit from Fumito Ueda on The Last Guardian. Can you tell us if you had any involvement in creating that game?

Dylan: No but I have always been friends with Ueda, ever since he showed me his first demo of Ico on the PlayStation 1. We sometimes meet up and discuss things.

James: How do you feel about the future of video games at this point in time? What is next for you and Q-Games? 

Dylan: I think there is a bit of a tipping point happening - which you can see from the enormous amount of layoffs in the West in the games industry. It is getting harder and harder to make a game that lifts its head out up above the sea of other games. I think people in the industry will need to get scrappier and hungrier and less complacent, and learn how to push themselves to make something that truly stands out. Following Miyamoto’s method can get you some of the way there, but we also all need to search hard to find that spark of inspiration that gives us the next hit and ignites the audience again.

Interview Transcript: Giles Goddard, November 2024

Giles Goddard was one of the first western employees at Nintendo, having moved to Japan from his native England along with fellow Argonaut Software programmers. At that time, he helped create and develop Star Fox, then programmed the stretchy Mario face in Super Mario 64, 1080 Snowboarding, and more.

For Retro Gamer Magazine number 266, I interviewed Giles to discuss his work on the second Super FX Chip game (following Star Fox), Stunt Race FX. Due to scope of focus and space, much of the interview was not included in the Retro Gamer piece. Here’s the full interview transcript.

---

James: Before I launch into the interview, I’d like to take a moment to thank you for your work and career.

I’ve read and listened to many interviews that you’ve given over the years, and I feel that you don’t take much time for professional retrospection, preferring to finish one project and get right on to the next. But I hope you know that your work has brought millions of people a lot of happiness.

I don’t want to miss the opportunity to thank you personally. I spent many happy days as a child playing your video games with my brother, and Stunt Race FX was a favorite of ours.

Giles: Many thanks for the kind words about the game and how much fun you had playing it with your brother. Its always really cool hearing from people that enjoyed playing one of my games in their childhood. I can honestly say I don’t think any of us thought people would still be talking fondly about the game 30 years later.

James: Starting at the beginning, where did the initial idea for Stunt Race FX come from?

Giles: I can’t remember exactly who’s idea it was originally but I think the idea was to make a sort of Super FX chip Mario Kart game. I always loved Geoff Crammond’s brilliant Stunt Car Racer so was very eager to make a racing game of my own using realistic physics. The characteristic vehicles with their googly eyes came much later in development I seem to remember. Like a lot of projects at EAD at that time it sort of evolved organically.

James: In interviews, you seem to be very pragmatic in your thinking and not prone to nostalgic reminiscence. But do you have any personal feeling toward Stunt Race FX or your time working on it?

Giles: I think I was just really eager to make a game using some ideas for car physics that I had been working on. I didn’t really have a clue what I was doing so it was very much a case of making it up as I went along. Also while I was at Argonaut I made a prototype game that I called XLR8  (I thought it was a cool name at the time:) but accidentally lost the entire thing when I wiped the wrong disk. This was long before the days of source control but I still think its good to start from scratch again sometimes.

James: Stunt Race FX was the second FX chip game released, following Star Fox. Did the experience of working on Star Fox influence Stunt Race FX, and in what ways?

Giles: Very much so. During Star Fox we were literally ironing out the bugs of the chip itself while trying to make the game so we learnt a lot of how to get the best out of the chip. By the time we started Stunt Race most of the bugs had already been fixed, or we had already figured out ways around the hardware bugs that remained. Also because the FX chip (we called it the MARIO chip at the time) was a very good general purpose RISC chip you could do things that it wasn’t really designed for in the first place. So we were still discovering new things it could do while making the game. One of the things we realized with Star Fox was that the FX chip was really good at scaling and rotating bitmaps, so we turned all of the wheels (and the eyes) into sprites instead of using polygons. That saved us a lot of draw time that using polygons would have taken up.

James: The cars of Stunt Race FX have very distinct handling characteristics. The 4WD truck feels top-heavy and disconnected from the road, for example, while the F1 style car is nimbler and more planted. It has been written that this is due to each car having a different center of gravity. Is this accurate? How were the different handling characteristics created?

Giles: When I made the original prototype it was great because I could work with a sort of blank slate when it came to the physics. It was just a single car on a flat track with no UI and nothing else slowing the FX chip down. It was a lovely 20-30 FPS and it allowed me to add all sorts of parameters to the physics to get different kinds of car handling. Of course with vehicles a big part of the way they handle has to do with their suspension and their CoG, so those parameters were good to fiddle with to get the feeling of different cars. I had a simple way to edit all the parameters in real-time without any real constraints so we definitely pushed them way beyond what was “realistic”.

Also I discovered that if you put the CoG under the ground it acts as a sort of keel of a boat and helps to keep the car upright, so I used that for the bike because I hadn’t found a good way to keep a two wheel vehicle upright by then.

James: Given the technical challenges of the time, can you mention any features or ideas that needed to be cut during development?

Giles: I think we might have had talk about a four-player mode before doing two- player but that was already pushing the FX chip to the max. So much so in fact that we were having to make each player’s screen smaller and smaller to keep the frame rate acceptable.

I think we also wanted more complex tracks but we were very much fill-rate limited by the FX chip so drawing the track alone was taking up a huge chunk of our frame time - we kind of cheated with Star Fox and drew dots instead of ground polygons and that freed the chip up to draw more enemies etc.

James: Obligatory Shigeru Miyamoto question; Miyamoto is credited as the producer of Stunt Race FX. Do you recall any input from the Nintendo legend on this game?

Giles: I think the eyes may have been his idea. By the time we had several cars driving around a track with effects and a UI we were a long way from the smooth 20 FPS of the prototype. But the problem was I hadn’t really built any of the physics with frame rate independence in mind so the physics started behaving in a odd ways. So I think we decided to lean into that instead of trying to fix it and it also gave all the cars some personality - as if they were alive and struggling to keep themselves together.   

James: Stunt Race FX included a split-screen multiplayer mode, which seemed ambitious for the time. Was it difficult to implement multiplayer in a game which (presumably) pushed the limits of the SNES hardware?

Giles: The biggest problem with split screen multiplayer is that each view has to draw the entire world, including all the other cars. So effectively you’re drawing twice as much as you would with single player and we were already maxing out the frame rate in single player mode. So we had to do all of the tricks to get it anywhere near acceptable - lower res shapes, simpler tracks, closer draw distance, letterbox screens etc. I think I kind of hated two-player mode because it felt like there was hardly any game left after all of the hoops we had to jump through. It was a crucial part of Nintendo’s racing games at the time though so it had to be done one way or another.

One of the things I think I was actually quite proud of at the time is oddly enough the water drops that appear on the screen when you go through water. That was one of those things that I knew the FX could theoretically do fast but I just had to figure out how to code it efficiently. I should probably go back and look at the code again though :)

James: Did anyone within Nintendo react to Stunt Race FX in a memorable way?

Giles: It was a long time ago so my memory is somewhat fuzzy, but if I can think of something I will let you know :)

James: The visual design of Stunt Race FX is very playful, almost toy-like. Was a more realistic aesthetic ever considered?

Giles: I think in the beginning we may have had ideas of making it realistic looking, but the way the physics behaved especially with the low frame rates ended up dictating the look of the game. Also it meant that we didn’t need to come up with player characters because the players could be the cars themselves.

James: Who came up with the idea of giving the cars eyes?

Giles: I vaguely remember it being Miyamoto san’s idea. But I could be wrong :) Everything looks better with eyes and I think we were all a fan of Herbie :)

James: Nintendo illustrator Wataru Yamaguchi created clay models of the game vehicles for Stunt Race FX’s box art and instruction manual. Why aren’t these models preserved in the Louvre?

Giles: Maybe not the Louvre but definitely the new museum that Nintendo have opened recently in Kyoto. Nintendo used to make physical models for several of their SNES games at the time so it would be amazing to see them all together again in real life.

James: You mentioned that you don’t often get asked about Stunt Race FX. The game sold over a million copies. Are you proud of this game?

Giles: My tendency to look at the flaws or things that I could have done differently end up quelling any thoughts of feeling proud of the games I worked on. But hearing from people who grew up playing my games and even some of them being a favorite game does make me very proud of what we made. At the end of the day people enjoying what we make is what really matters the most.

James: Thank you once again. I truly appreciate you.

Interview Transcript: Richard Jacques, Feb 2024

jhkjh